I've notice on this forum and others that a decent handful of people switched to a Renegade after their older Liberty just wasn't cutting it. Over on Jalopnik, they have a bit of a takedown on the Liberty. A sample: "The problem with the Liberty is the quintessential problem of all truly Meh cars: who gives a shit? It wasn’t an especially good off-roader, it wasn’t a really comfortable or full-featured SUV, its engine was sort of underpowered for the weight, the re-design got rid of any interesting design cues, and it wasn’t even as crappy as the Patriot or Compass, so it can’t even be notable for sucking dramatically. "The Liberty, like all meh cars, wasn’t horrible: the 3.7-liter Powertech V6 made 210 horsepower and wasn’t that bad, the interior space was about on par with any number of other boring SUVs, and it could do some off-roading, if you wanted. It did its basic job with delirious adequacy." The article and the comments are a pretty amusing read. Any Liberty fans or haters out there?